Monday 9 September 2013

YA REVIEW - 'Tomorrow, When The War Began', John Marsden (Quercus, 2011) (first published 1993)

When Ellie and her friends return from a camping trip in the Australian bush, they find things hideously wrong — their families are gone. Gradually they begin to comprehend that their country has been invaded and everyone in their town has been taken prisoner. As the reality of the situation hits them, they must make a decision — run and hide, give themselves up and be with their families, or fight back. (Synopsis from Goodreads)

Tomorrow When the War Began (Tomorrow, #1)
I can't believe I'm saying this but I'd completely forgotten about John Marsden. Ridiculous, I know. The first book I'd read of his was when I was living in Brisbane, near a local library stocked to the hilt with titles from this Australian YA genius, so I had my pick of all the beautiful words. His contemporary stuff (ok, it's not strictly speaking up-to-the-minute contemporary) rocked me to my very core, making it even more astonishing that he'd fallen off my radar over the last 18 months. So when I saw the Kindle edition of probably his most famous book (is this his most famous book? Any Aussies out there, please feel free to correct me) on offer, all the feels came flooding back. I was surely in for a guaranteed gripping read, wasn't I? Well...

I was a bit disappointed with this one to be honest. It pains me to admit it, but there were times when it became a bit of an effort. How is this possible from such a brilliant wordsmith? And a brilliant wordsmith doing dystopian? Sure, there was plenty of the fantastic trademark prose peppered across the chapters, but I felt so let down by how this story panned out. Choosing to write in a diary format didn't really help with the development of the plot and the characters. We do get to know Ellie really well, and I loved Ellie - so self-assured and confident and comfortable in her own skin - but with such a large cast, most of the others blended into the back ground, especially the girls. We're given scant outlines of their personalities, but shown very little evidence of them in action, especially the best friend Corrie. The boys were slightly better developed, but I never felt a connection or empathy with any of them. Kind of a weakness in a story which uses a strong group dynamic as its base.

Another disadvantage of using Ellie's diary to convey the action was that I was left with no sense of tension or danger. For example, at one point Ellie is writing down how Robyn recounted her escape from the soldiers. A fairly dramatic incident you might imagine - and yet their in no drama whatsoever, because we know Robyn is safe because she is there telling the story! And sometimes, the whole thing felt a bit like I was reading a Bear Grylls-style survival handbook - pages and pages of detailed dialogue describing what they were planning to do, their contingency plans if something went awry, what they did, what they shouldn't do, what they might do but probably don't have time to do.....etc etc. Not exactly snappy.

And then the romance - I just didn't get it. It came out of nowhere and what might have been a fairly promising love triangle (and I'm not usually a fan of love triangles) was dispensed with rather quickly, which left me wondering why he even bothered with it in the first place.

But my main problem was that I just didn't buy it. Any of it. Would they really be so clueless about an impending war? Why would there parents be happy for them to disappear off camping if such a war was looming? And then once the war started, they still didn't have a clue who the invaders were? Really? Perhaps all these questions are answered in the other books in the series. I'm still not a hundred percent sure whether I'll be picking them up to find out.


9 comments:

  1. I love this series.

    The first one is definitely the weakest though. It's kind of "safe" and restrained in a way the subsequent novels - where the tone is more apocalyptic and melancholic, the romance is a lot less chaste, and action is bloodier and more exhausting (but in a good way) - aren't.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Ok, maybe I'll give the other books a go. I think perhaps my expectations were a bit too high :)

      Delete
  2. A good review, which I sort of agree with even though I love the books (the first 3 anyway).
    The film is worth a couple of hours of anybody's time, if you like that sort of thing.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks :) I've been meaning to watch the film for a while but I wanted to read the book first.

      Delete
  3. Oh no! This series was what got me back into YA a few years ago so it sits on my beloved bookshelf but... I wonder if I would feel the same about it now that I've been reading so much great YA? I cracked up at the Bear Grylls survival handbook line. I don't think any of them have to drink their own urine. I hope you continue on with the series! (I didn't like the movie very much. Sorry, commenter above me.)

    -Maggie

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I have loved loved loved every other one of his books so far, so maybe I want just being overly-pernickety? (not completely unheard of) Might give the film a go out of curiosity...

      Delete
  4. I don't remember feeling as critical as you of this first book when I read it awhile back. In fact, I liked it enough to read the next book... though I haven't read any more in this series (which is telling!)

    I do completely agree that the romance in the first book seemed entirely unneccessary and out of nowhere.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The fact that's there are 7 books in the series as well as another 3 of The Ellie Chronicles (I think) puts me of I bit - I think I might as well give up now!

      Yes the romance was...rubbish

      Delete
  5. I have a confession: I tried to read this once and didn't get past chapter 2. It really didn't grab my attention and I remember being totally confused by all the people and lack of dialogue tags. I've never read any of his other stuff - I feel so unAustralian right now haha!

    ReplyDelete